The Everyman’s Rye

Tincup introduces an instantly likable rye.

Tincup American Whisky was founded with a mission: Make whiskey approachable for all. Now, the brand has a rye that lives up to that promise.

Typically, ryes are considered whiskey 2.0. They are spicier, drier, and pack a bite, hence best appreciated by a more advanced palate. Whiskey and bourbon, on the other hand, are made mostly from corn mash, which yields a high sugar content that makes them easier to drink. “We wanted to make a rye that you don’t have to learn to like,” says Tincup’s cowboy-founder Jess Graber, who also founded Stranahan’s Whiskey in 2002.

EO had a chance to try the new label at a recent tasting in Tincup, Colorado, the mining town that inspired the brand, and found it to be easy drinking, indeed. We picked out flavors of wood and leather and a finish of apricot and pepper, and found it had a bit of sweetness to mellow out the heat. Rather than the horse-kick finish characteristic of most ryes. “Tincup gives you a little love bite that lets you know you’re still alive,” says Graber in his characteristic salt-of-the-earth style.

Graber attributes the drinkability to the “best water in the world,” sourced from Colorado’s Eldorado Springs, and the charred American white oak barrels it’s aged in for three years.

The barrels extract impurities, lend a sweet caramel flavor, and tame down the kick, he says.

“I’m not a rocket scientist,” Graber adds. “We just make good whiskey.”

Related Stories


YMCA of the Rockies, Colorado Perfect Winter

At Two Beloved Locations—Estes Park Center and Snow Mountain Ranch— YMCA of the Rockies Offers Up Top-notch Programming for the 2022–23 Winter Season That...

Winter, Summer, and Everything in Between

The Adventures are Year-Round at RMOC  Let the seasons determine your stoke with the help of Rocky Mountain Outdoor Center. A prime location in Buena...

How to Make Your Outdoor Cabin More Weather Resistant

As residents throughout the Rocky Mountain region continue to explore barndominium cost vs house prices to help find an affordable place to live, the...

Eldora is the Perfect Escape

If you’re seeking that private hill feeling with up-front parking, zero lift lines, and wide-open slopes, Eldora is your winter weekend destination. And with...